Taxes are a necessary evil. They are the cost of running our government. However, raising taxes too much ultimately reduces the total value received. Many economists believe the paradox that the more you tax, after a certain point, the less total revenue you collect thus reaching a tipping point. Legislators should consider “How many taxes are too many; have we reached a tipping point; when do more taxes create diminishing returns and result in lower total tax revenues? ”.
Data strongly suggests Connecticut has reached or exceeded a tax tipping point after enacting historically high back to back tax increases in 2011 and 2015. This resulted in flat total tax revenues from 2013 to 2015. In 2016 revenue actually fell 1.9%.
Despite these compelling facts, a newly elected legislature is considering a tsunami of new taxes: tolls, state wide property tax, replacing the local car tax with a state-wide car tax, millionaires’ tax, home heating oil tax, a second electricity tax and legal, accounting and veterinary services taxes.
Legislators are even proposing taxes on: sugary drinks, plastic bags, groceries, textbooks, non-prescription drugs, alcoholic beverage bottles, haircuts, dry cleaners, real estate, boat storage, interior design, newspapers/magazines, waste collection, parking, renovations and repairs, car trade-ins, helmets, car seats, camps, sports programs, swim lessons, licenses for cats.
Many Connecticut residents are fleeing to states that are embracing the concept that if you tax less you will attract new taxpayers and thereby revenues. These states face the same daunting task of providing public safety, education, transportation and social services; however, they have chosen to reduce tax rates to stimulate their economies and have successfully increased their total tax revenues.
- North Carolina revenues grew 3.8% in 2016. As a result it will reduce its 5.49% income tax to 5.24% in 2019. It also will reduce corporate tax to the lowest in the nation at 2.5% and will repeal it as more businesses move in and revenues increase.
- New Hampshire, a state with no income tax, is reducing corporate taxes two years in a row as a result of revenue growth of 2%.
- Georgia is also reducing income and corporate taxes in 2019 as a result of strong revenue growth rate of 4.5%.
- Tennessee only taxes interest and dividends and reduced tax rates from 6 to 3% as its population grew 6.7% from 2010-2017 and revenues increased 2.4%.
- States with no income taxes like Florida, Texas and Nevada had revenue growth rates between 3 to 7.6% from 2015-2016 due to population increases of nearly 2%.
Connecticut, with a top income tax rate of nearly 7%, has had zero % population increase from 2010-2018 and flat revenue growth from 2013-2016. Alarmingly, its job growth rate has dropped nearly every year since 2011 and is rapidly decelerating. Connecticut remains the only state in the Northeast that has yet to recover jobs lost in the last recession.
Lawmakers should consider that other historic tax increases stalled economic recovery, reduced revenues and lowered property values as people and jobs left. Homes values are down by nearly 50% in Fairfield County. Once the tipping point is reached, further taxation will accelerate a downward spiral.
Since the 2018 election, the tax floodgates have opened. A new progressive caucus has set its eyes on businesses and the highest income taxpayers who already carry the lion’s share of the tax burden.
The new administration and legislators should follow the example of growing states that are reducing taxes, not increasing them. This is a proven way to grow the tax base and generate the revenues needed to fund essential services such as public safety, education, transportation and social services. Connecticut needs to breathe life back into its economy and tip the scales back in favor of prosperity.
Toni Boucher is a Connecticut Businesswoman and former Senate Vice Chairman of the Finance, Revenue and Bonding Committee of the Legislature
Sources: The Tax Foundations, Foundation of Tax Administrators, US Census